I for one did not read the book. Actually, I barely heard of the movie, my wife picked this up for us to watch with the kids before we watched our movie. It turned out to be an excellent animated movie with emphasis on movie. What I appreciated about Tale of Despereaux was the fact it had a story to tell and it was done very well. This is not just another animated fluff movie full of one liners and stupidity. It has enough action to keep the young's attention, of course what's an animated movie without a few talking animals and a magical character who goes from assistant chef to....... well I won't let that out of the bag. I also appreciate the fact this movie takes the time to develope the main characters, you understand the reason they do what they do, it makes you feel for the characters, whether you like them or not, your opinion could even change on certain characters as the movie unfolds, and no loose ends are left hanging at the end of the movie. The plot is not predictable as many of the Hollywood carbon copy dribble is today. I found Tale of Despereaux an entertaining movie that kept my attention as a 40 something, my grandson's, who is 4, and feel it can do the same for all ages. I personally hope to see more animation coming out that has this type of depth to the story. As some one already mentioned this is an excellent family movie and done cleverly so. For instance, one place in the movie a character sneaks a knife out of the kitchen, as an adult you know full well what is going on but the knife is never shown again. Another place it is incenuated one character will eat the other but they go through a door which closes behind them. And, whether you understand fully what happens there is really irrelevant because justice was served and a bad guy is out of the movie, which was the point. What I'm trying to say is children will still understand the story as it's done here without graffic deeds being shown.When you make a movie based on a book it's inevitable that comparisons will be made and people will be interested to know if it follows the book line by line but it should stop there. Try to judge the movie based on it's own stand alone merits. It's entertainment, not a history lesson. So I hope people will enjoy this fine film and not rip on it because they feel the maker violated some sacred writing.